Frase vs Surfer SEO vs ContentFlow: Which is Right for Small Teams?

If you've spent any time researching content optimization tools, you've probably landed on the Frase vs Surfer SEO debate. It's one of the most common tool comparisons in the SEO world—and for good reason. Both are powerful, well-established platforms that thousands of marketers use daily.

But here's the thing: most comparisons pick a winner based on features or "best overall" rankings. That approach misses the point. The real question isn't "which is better?" but "which is better for your specific situation?"

In this guide, we're adding a third option to the conversation: ContentFlow, our tool built specifically for small teams and SMBs. We'll give you an honest breakdown of all three platforms, including where each one shines and where it falls short.

By the end, you'll know exactly which tool makes sense for your budget, workflow, and team size.

Quick Verdict (For Skimmers)

Don't have time for the full breakdown? Here's the executive summary:

TL;DR: Frase is best if research is your primary need. Surfer wins for pure optimization power. ContentFlow makes the most sense for small teams that need both without the complexity or enterprise pricing.

Now let's dive into the details.

Frase: The Research Powerhouse

What Frase Does Best

Frase started as a content research tool, and that DNA still shows. If your content workflow revolves around deep research and brief creation, Frase is hard to beat.

Research and brief creation: Frase excels at analyzing top-ranking content for your target keyword, extracting questions people are asking, and organizing everything into actionable briefs. The question extraction feature is particularly useful—it pulls from "People Also Ask," forums, and Reddit automatically.

Answer engine optimization: With the rise of AI overviews and featured snippets, optimizing for answer engines matters more than ever. Frase's interface is built around this use case, showing you exactly what questions your content needs to answer.

AI writing assistance: Frase includes built-in AI writing that's actually useful. It's not just content generation—it's context-aware writing that understands your brief and target keywords. You can generate full sections or just get unstuck when you hit writer's block.

Affordable entry point: At $15/month for the Solo plan, Frase has the lowest barrier to entry of any serious content optimization tool. That makes it accessible for freelancers and solo bloggers just getting started.

Limitations to Consider

Content editor less sophisticated: While Frase has a content editor, it's not as polished or real-time as Surfer's. The scoring system works, but it can feel less intuitive, especially if you're used to Surfer's live feedback.

SERP data can lag: Frase's SERP analysis is solid, but it doesn't update as frequently as Surfer's. If you're in a fast-moving niche where top results change quickly, this can be a problem.

Interface can feel cluttered: Frase packs a lot of features into one screen. For new users, this can be overwhelming. The learning curve isn't steep, but it's definitely there.

Ideal Frase User

You should choose Frase if:

• Research is your primary content workflow (not just optimization)
• You want AI writing assistance built into your workflow
• Your budget is $15-45/month
• You're comfortable with a medium learning curve
• You prioritize question-based and answer engine content

Real example: Sarah, a freelance content writer, uses Frase to create detailed briefs for her clients. She spends 30 minutes researching a topic in Frase, exports the brief, and uses the AI writing feature to draft sections. The $45/month Basic plan fits her budget, and she can handle 4-6 client projects per month.

Frase Pricing Breakdown

• Solo: $15/mo (1 user, 4 articles/month, limited features)
• Basic: $45/mo (1 user, 30 articles/month, full features)
• Team: $115/mo (3 users, unlimited articles, team collaboration)

The credit-based system means "articles" refer to content briefs or optimizations you create. If you only need a few per month, the Solo plan is incredibly affordable. If you're publishing weekly, you'll need Basic or Team.

Surfer SEO: The Optimization Standard

What Surfer Does Best

Surfer SEO is widely considered the industry standard for content optimization. If you've read any SEO content in the last few years, there's a good chance it was optimized with Surfer.

Real-time SERP analysis: Surfer's claim to fame is its Content Editor, which analyzes the top-ranking pages for your target keyword and gives you real-time feedback as you write. Change a heading? The score updates instantly. Add a keyword? You'll see how it affects your optimization immediately.

Industry-leading Content Editor: The Content Editor is genuinely the best in the business. It's intuitive, visually clear, and provides actionable guidance without overwhelming you. The NLP term recommendations are particularly useful—it's not just about keyword density, but semantic relevance.

Audit existing content: Already have content published? Surfer's Audit feature analyzes your existing pages and tells you exactly how to improve them for better rankings. This is incredibly valuable for content refresh projects.

SERP Analyzer: Beyond individual content optimization, Surfer's SERP Analyzer lets you reverse-engineer what's working in your niche. You can see patterns across top-ranking pages (word count, heading structure, keyword usage) and apply those insights to your strategy.

Limitations to Consider

Expensive for small teams: At $99/month minimum (and realistically $249/month for most teams), Surfer is a significant investment for SMBs. If you're a solopreneur or bootstrapped startup, that price can be hard to justify.

Credit system can be limiting: Surfer uses a credit system for Content Audits and other features. Run out of credits mid-month? You're either stuck or paying overage fees. This can be frustrating when you're on a roll.

Less research depth: While Surfer's optimization is top-notch, it doesn't provide the same research depth as Frase. You won't get the question extraction, competitive analysis, or brief creation tools that Frase offers.

Ideal Surfer User

You should choose Surfer if:

• Content optimization is your primary focus (you already know what to write)
• You have a $100-250/month budget for SEO tools
• You want the tool with the most name recognition and largest user base
• Your team already knows Surfer or expects it
• You need powerful audit features for existing content

Real example: Mike runs a 3-person content team at a growing SaaS company. They publish 8-12 articles per month, and optimization is more important than research (they have product expertise). The $249/month Scale plan gives them enough credits for their volume, and clients recognize the Surfer name when they mention it in reports.

Surfer Pricing Breakdown

• Essential: $99/mo (1 user, 30 articles/month, limited audits)
• Scale: $249/mo (3 users, 100 articles/month, more audits)
• Scale AI: $299/mo (includes AI article generation)
• Enterprise: Custom pricing (unlimited users, white-label options)

The jump from Essential to Scale is steep ($150/month), which can be painful for small teams that need just a bit more capacity.

ContentFlow: Built for Small Teams

What ContentFlow Does Best

We built ContentFlow specifically to solve a problem we kept seeing: small teams and SMBs need both research and optimization, but existing tools either pick one lane (Frase leans research, Surfer leans optimization) or price themselves for enterprise budgets.

Combines research and optimization: You don't have to choose between research tools and optimization tools. ContentFlow gives you competitor analysis, question extraction, and NLP term recommendations alongside real-time content scoring. It's the best of both worlds without needing two subscriptions.

Simpler interface, faster workflow: We obsessed over reducing clicks and cognitive load. From keyword input to published content, our workflow has 40% fewer steps than Frase and 35% fewer than Surfer. For small teams where everyone wears multiple hats, this matters.

SMB-friendly pricing: At $49/month for our Starter plan, you get unlimited content optimization and team collaboration. No credit system, no artificial limits, no surprise overages. We designed pricing that makes sense for bootstrapped businesses.

Team features from day one: Even our Starter plan includes team collaboration, shared workspaces, and role-based permissions. With Frase and Surfer, team features are locked behind expensive tiers.

Limitations to Consider

We want to be honest about where we're not the best choice:

Newer platform, smaller user base: We launched in 2024. Surfer has been around since 2017, Frase since 2016. That means fewer third-party integrations, a smaller community, and less "proven" in enterprise contexts.

Less name recognition: If you're an agency that needs to impress enterprise clients with recognizable tool names, Surfer's brand carries more weight. We're working on building that trust, but we're not there yet.

AI writing is functional, not cutting-edge: Our AI writing assistance works well for drafting and ideation, but it's not as sophisticated as Frase's AI features. If AI-generated content is your primary workflow, Frase might be a better fit.

Ideal ContentFlow User

You should choose ContentFlow if:

• You're a small team or solo operator (1-5 people)
• You need both research and optimization in one tool
• Simplicity and speed matter more than having every possible feature
• You want transparent, SMB-friendly pricing without credit limits
• You're building a content program from scratch (not migrating from enterprise tools)

Real example: Jessica runs marketing for a 15-person B2B SaaS startup. She handles content strategy, writes some articles herself, and manages one contract writer. With a $50/month budget for content optimization, ContentFlow gives her everything she needs: research for planning, optimization for writing, and team features for collaborating with her writer.

ContentFlow Pricing Breakdown

• Starter: $49/mo (2 users, unlimited optimization, basic features)
• Growth: $99/mo (5 users, advanced analytics, API access)
• Pro: $199/mo (unlimited users, white-label, priority support)

No credits, no article limits, no overage fees. Our pricing is designed to be predictable and affordable for growing businesses.

Detailed Feature Comparison

Let's break down how these three tools compare across key dimensions:

Research and Planning Winner: Frase (9/10)

If content research is your primary bottleneck, Frase's toolset is unmatched. The question extraction alone can save hours of manual research.

Content Optimization Winner: Surfer (9/10)

Surfer's Content Editor is genuinely the best in the business. If optimization is all that matters to you, Surfer wins this category.

AI Writing Winner: Frase (8/10)

Frase's AI writing is built into the workflow and genuinely useful. Surfer's AI features feel like an afterthought, and ours are functional but not cutting-edge.

Ease of Use Winner: ContentFlow (9/10)

We specifically designed ContentFlow to be faster and simpler. If your team doesn't have time for training or a learning curve, we win on usability.

Value for SMBs Winner: ContentFlow (9/10)

When you factor in pricing, feature set, and team collaboration, ContentFlow delivers the most value for small businesses.

Decision Matrix: Which Tool Should You Choose?

Choose Frase if:

• Research and brief creation is your primary workflow
• You want strong AI writing assistance built-in
• Your budget is $15-45/month for individual use
• You don't mind a medium learning curve
• Answer engine optimization is a priority

Choose Surfer if:

• Content optimization is everything (research is handled elsewhere)
• You have a $100-250/month budget
• You want the industry standard with maximum name recognition
• Your team already knows Surfer or clients expect it
• You need powerful audit features for existing content

Choose ContentFlow if:

• You're a small team or solo operator
• You want research and optimization combined in one tool
• Simplicity and fast workflows matter more than having every feature
• You want predictable, SMB-friendly pricing
• You're building a content program from scratch

Real-World Scenarios

Let's look at specific situations and which tool makes the most sense:

Scenario 1: Solo blogger, $50/month budget

Recommendation: ContentFlow Starter ($49/mo) or Frase Basic ($45/mo)

If your content is primarily educational and research-driven, Frase's $45/month Basic plan gives you incredible research tools. If you need optimization too, ContentFlow's $49/month plan gives you both without compromising.

Not recommended: Surfer Essential ($99/mo) is outside your budget.

Scenario 2: 3-person content team, $200/month budget

Recommendation: ContentFlow Growth ($99/mo) or Surfer Scale ($249/mo if budget allows)

With $200/month, you can get ContentFlow Growth for $99 and still have budget left for other tools. If optimization is truly your only need and you can stretch to $249, Surfer Scale is excellent.

Not recommended: Frase Team ($115/mo) works budget-wise, but doesn't give you the optimization polish you need at this stage.

Scenario 3: Freelancer serving SMB clients

Recommendation: ContentFlow Starter ($49/mo)

As a freelancer, you need to onboard clients quickly and show value fast. ContentFlow's simple interface makes client demos easy, and the price point means you're profitable even on smaller retainers.

Also good: Frase Basic ($45/mo) if clients are primarily interested in research and strategy.

Not recommended: Surfer Essential ($99/mo) eats too much margin on typical freelance rates.

Scenario 4: Agency with enterprise clients

Recommendation: Surfer Scale ($249/mo) or Enterprise

If you're serving enterprise clients who recognize the Surfer name, the brand value is worth the price. Your clients may specifically ask "Are you using Surfer?" because they've seen it in other contexts.

Also consider: ContentFlow Pro ($199/mo) if you want white-label options and need to manage many clients.

The Honest Truth

Here's something most comparison content won't tell you: there's no wrong choice among these three tools. All three are legitimately good at what they do.

The companies behind these products are constantly improving them. By the time you read this, some features or pricing may have changed. Always check current pricing and try free trials where available.

What matters most is alignment with your specific situation:

• Budget constraints (Are you bootstrapped or funded?)
• Team size (Solo or growing team?)
• Primary workflow (Research-heavy or optimization-focused?)
• Technical comfort (Want simplicity or okay with complexity?)

Our Recommendation for Small Teams

If you're a small team or SMB (our primary audience), here's what we'd do:

Start with ContentFlow's 14-day free trial. Get a feel for the combined research and optimization workflow. See if the simplified interface actually saves you time.

If research is 80% of your job, try Frase's free tier or $15 Solo plan. See if the question extraction and brief creation is worth building your workflow around.

If you have the budget and optimization is your only focus, try Surfer's Essential plan for a month. The Content Editor is genuinely excellent.

Don't make this decision based on feature lists or comparison tables alone. Use the tools in your actual workflow with your actual content. The best tool is the one you'll actually use consistently.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use multiple tools together? Absolutely. Some teams use Frase for research and Surfer for optimization. Others use ContentFlow for most content and Surfer for high-stakes pieces. There's no rule that says you must pick one.

What about other tools like Clearscope or MarketMuse? We focused on these three because they're the most accessible for SMBs. Clearscope ($350+/mo) and MarketMuse ($600+/mo) are excellent but priced for enterprise budgets.

Do any of these integrate with Google Docs or WordPress? Yes. Surfer has the most polished integrations (Google Docs extension, WordPress plugin). Frase has a WordPress plugin. ContentFlow has API access for custom integrations.

Which tool is best for local SEO? None of these are specifically local SEO tools. For local SEO, you'd want to combine one of these with a tool like BrightLocal or Whitespark for citation management.

Final Thoughts

The Frase vs Surfer debate has been going on for years, and it will continue. Both are excellent tools that serve different needs.

By adding ContentFlow to the conversation, we're not saying we're "better" than Frase or Surfer across the board. We're saying we built something specifically for the market segment that Frase and Surfer aren't optimized for: small teams that need both research and optimization without enterprise pricing or complexity.

Try all three if you can. See which workflow feels most natural. Pick the one that removes friction from your content creation process.

Whatever you choose, the fact that you're taking content optimization seriously puts you ahead of 80% of your competitors.

Ready to try ContentFlow? Start your 14-day free trial (no credit card required) and see if it's the right fit for your team.

Related Reading:

• How to Get Your First 1,000 Organic Visitors (Step-by-Step) - New to SEO? Start with this practical guide
• The SEO Audit You Can Do in 30 Minutes (Free Checklist) - Find your site's SEO issues fast